A Conversation with Elaine Troisi on: The Relationship With Readers
“I write the story. But the reader helps bring it to life.”
What it feels like to be read, seen, and interpreted
💡 Quick Look
• Author interviewed: Elaine Troisi
• Focus: How readers shape the work, from practical feedback to solving the ending of a novel
• Key insight: “I write the story. But the reader helps bring it to life.” A reader’s suggestion of letters inside the urn became the perfect bridge between past and present in The Urn.
• Core idea: The author–reader relationship is a partnership. Disagreement is not rejection; it is part of making the story more alive.
For Elaine Troisi, writing is never a solitary act, even when it begins that way. Her words are shaped not only by intention, but by the presence of the reader: imagined, real, and deeply valued. In this reflection, she shares how readers influence her work, challenge her thinking, and ultimately help bring her stories to life.
The Conversation
The Importance of the Reader
I have the need to write. I write to be read. Through my words, I communicate the words in my heart, the truths in my soul, and the wisdom of my years.
A writer needs a reader.
To me, the reader is everything.
When Readers Speak And Change the Story
From a technical perspective, reader feedback has shaped my writing in practical ways. One reader advised me to alter my style, suggesting longer paragraphs to balance my dialogue-heavy storytelling. Another recommended clearer chapter headings to guide readers through dual timelines, such as in The Urn: A Legacy of Silence. And many asked for a larger, darker font, especially appreciated by older readers.
You may think these comments miss the point. But they don’t. Every piece of feedback matters. I have taken these suggestions to heart while working on my current novel, The Cottage.
But sometimes, a reader does more than refine your writing, they transform it.
One reader helped me solve the ending of The Urn. I struggled with how to connect past and present. I knew the urn held secrets but how could those secrets reach across time?
The suggestion was simple and brilliant: letters placed inside the urn, written in the past to be read in the present.
It became the perfect conclusion.
The voices of the past could finally speak.
Writing With the Reader Beside Me
As I write, my characters always come first: their motivations, fears, flaws, and desires.
But the reader is never far away.
I imagine a reader sitting beside me, like a quiet literary critic:
“Have you explained this clearly?”
“Is this too much?”
“Get to the point, Elaine.”
Sometimes I don’t like what that voice says, but I listen.
The reader is not just an audience.
The reader is my partner and my guide.
The Author and Reader: A Partnership
Perhaps the relationship between an author and a reader is a little like a marriage.
We don't always agree. A reader may question a choice I have made, suggest something I had never considered, or see a character or situation completely differently from the way I intended. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.
Like any good partnership, the goal isn't to agree on everything. It is to work together toward something meaningful.
I bring the story, the characters, the questions and the words. The reader brings perspective, interpretation, emotion and experience. Sometimes the reader challenges me. Sometimes I change my mind. Sometimes we simply see things differently.
But we are still working toward the same thing: making the story as meaningful and alive as it can possibly be.
That is why I don't see criticism or disagreement as a rejection of my work. The reader has entered the relationship with the story, and that relationship matters.
A writer needs a reader.
And perhaps, just like in a marriage, the beauty lies not in always seeing things the same way, but in caring enough to keep listening.
What It Means to Stay With a Reader
Of course, I hope readers enjoy my books. I hope they close them and think, “I liked that. I want to read more.”
But what matters most comes later.
When they pick up another book and think, “I hope this is as good as the last one.”
That’s when a story truly stays with someone.
That’s when it becomes part of them.
A Shared Journey
Emily Dickinson once wrote, “Forever is composed of nows.”
The past does not disappear, it becomes part of who we are. And sometimes, it takes a reader to help a writer see that connection.
Dickinson wrote in solitude, yet it was her sister who ensured her words reached the world.
A writer may begin alone.
But a story is never complete without a reader.
A Gentle Invitation
If you are a reader, know this: your voice matters more than you think. Your thoughts, your reactions, even your questions can shape a story in ways the writer never expected. When you connect with a book, you become part of it.
Stay Connected
To explore Elaine Troisi’s work, including The Urn: A Legacy of Silence and upcoming projects like The Cottage, visit her website:
Elaine Troisi Official Website
Your presence as a reader is not passive; it is powerful.
Originally published on Hidden Voices
Author Conversation by Roberta Maretti
Featured author: Elaine Troisi
Theme: The relationship with readers — partnership, feedback, and being read