Rewriting the Definition of “Success” as an Indie Author

What does success really mean when you are an indie author? Sales and recognition matter, but they are not the only measures. Sometimes we need to stop chasing someone else’s definition and decide what success means to us.

Share
Rewriting the Definition of “Success” as an Indie Author
Photo by Mohamed Nohassi / Unsplash

💡 Quick Look

• Topic: What success really means for indie authors
• Main idea: Sales, rankings, and visibility matter, but they are not the only measures. Success can also mean finishing the story you needed to tell, reaching the right reader, or simply still writing. The definition can change as you do.
• Key takeaway: You do not have to keep wearing a version of success that no longer fits. Maybe success is about becoming the author you are proud to be.

At some point, most indie authors have to decide what success actually means to them.

It sounds like a simple question until you realise how many answers you have absorbed without ever choosing them yourself.

Success can look like sales, rankings, bestseller lists, thousands of followers, glowing reviews, a growing mailing list, recognition from other authors, or the moment someone tells you that your book stayed with them long after they finished reading it.

The difficult part is that all of these things can matter, and yet none of them necessarily tells you whether you are succeeding at the thing you actually wanted to do.

When you first begin writing, it can be very easy to borrow someone else's definition of success.

You see an author announcing a huge launch. Someone celebrates reaching a particular sales number. Another writer talks about being in the charts, signing with an agent, collecting awards or gaining thousands of followers.

You look at all of it and quietly measure yourself against it.

Maybe you start wondering whether your own progress counts.

That comparison can become exhausting because the goal keeps moving. Once you reach one number, another appears. Once you achieve one milestone, someone else seems to have reached a bigger one.

Eventually, you can find yourself chasing a version of success that was never really yours.

I think that is when it becomes worth asking a different question.

What did you actually want when you decided to write?

Maybe you wanted to tell a story that had been sitting inside you for years. Maybe you wanted to prove to yourself that you could finish a book. Maybe you wanted to write something you would have loved to read yourself. Maybe writing became important because it gave you a way to make sense of something you had experienced.

Maybe you simply wanted to become an author.

Those things can sound small beside impressive sales figures, but they are not small if they mattered enough to make you begin.

And maybe success needs to include them.

That does not mean pretending that sales do not matter. They do. Most indie authors would like their books to sell, and there is nothing wrong with wanting to make money from your writing.

The problem begins when sales become the only evidence you allow yourself to use.

A book can sell quietly and still matter. A book can reach fewer people than you hoped and still reach the right person.

A reader who writes to tell you that a character reminded them of someone they loved may never appear on a sales dashboard, but that moment is real.

So is the satisfaction of holding your finished book for the first time. So is finally writing the story you were afraid you could not write. So is learning how to publish, edit, format, market and keep going when none of it comes naturally.

So is becoming better at the craft. So is discovering that you have something to say.

These things do not replace financial success. They simply remind us that financial success is only one part of the picture.

I also think success changes as we change.

The goal you had when you published your first book may not be the goal you have five years later. What once felt enormously important may eventually seem less significant. Something you barely noticed before may become the thing you value most.

Maybe you once wanted visibility and now you want freedom. Maybe you once wanted thousands of readers and now you would rather have a smaller group of readers who genuinely care about your work.

Maybe you once wanted to write constantly and now you want writing to fit comfortably alongside the rest of your life. Maybe you once wanted to prove that you could do it, and now you simply want to enjoy doing it.

None of that means you have become less ambitious. It means your definition of success has become more personal.

That may be one of the quiet advantages of being an indie author.

We have more freedom to decide what kind of writing life we actually want. That freedom comes with uncertainty, of course. Without a traditional structure telling us what the next milestone should be, we have to decide for ourselves, and that can be frightening. But it can also be liberating.

You are allowed to want a bestseller. You are allowed to want a modest income from your books. You are allowed to write one book every few years. You are allowed to write every day.

You are allowed to measure success by the number of readers you reach, the freedom your writing gives you, the stories you finish, or simply the fact that you are still writing.

You are also allowed to change your mind and maybe that is the real point.

Success is not a permanent destination that we reach once and then have to defend. It can change as our lives, priorities and reasons for writing change.

The version of success that mattered to you when you began may no longer fit the person you are now.

You do not have to keep wearing it just because you once chose it.

Maybe success is not about becoming the author everyone else notices. Maybe it is about becoming the author you are proud to be.

And maybe that is a definition worth rewriting.

Originally published on Hidden Voices

Indie Life reflection by Roberta Maretti
Theme: Redefining success on your own terms